Posted: Nov 26 2014

 Caryocorbula dietziana (C. B. Adams, 1852), Diet's Rose Corbula

Caryocorbuladietziana1
Caryocorbuladietziana1
press to zoom
RevofNo2
RevofNo2
press to zoom
Caryocorbuladietziana3
Caryocorbuladietziana3
press to zoom
Caryocorbuladietziana4
Caryocorbuladietziana4
press to zoom
Caryocorbulacontracta3
Caryocorbulacontracta3
press to zoom
RevofNo5contracta
RevofNo5contracta
press to zoom

Posted: Nov 28 2014 on LTS forum:

I posted notice of my presentations of C. contracta and C. dietziana on Conch-L and received the following comments about these difficult species. My personal opinion is that Say's description of C. contracta based upon only two specimens from the same geographic population is probably not reflective of the variability present in this taxon. However, it is apparent that these two are distinct species if only based upon anecdotal evidence that the unique adult stage of C. dietziana has not been reported where large populations of C. contracta have been found. My research (and library) is limited and we can only expand our insight if a large sample of C. contracta material from diverse locations can be comparatively presented with further confirmation that adult C. dietziana were not found in the same location.

Harry Lee:

"Rather the than the Say (1822) reference, you provide the C.B. Adams (1852) citation in your discussion of C. contracta." (Marlo: Thanks for noting error. Corrected! I should also note that Harry has been very adament in his perspective over the years in helping me address the confusion regarding the Western Atlantic Corbulids.)


David Kirsh:

"Bravo for taking these on, Marlo! I know you had been reluctant to tackle Corbulas several years ago. I believe C. contracta is the common species in the genus in North Carolina. The members of this genus are difficult to distinguish in my estimation."


steve rosenthal:

"I have dietziana from Jim Moore dredgings 95 Miles off Egmont Key, FL in the Gulf of Mexico.

re C contracta: As noted in the Long Island Shell Club's Seashells
of Long Island (1988) recent local records were few and far between, and always in small numbers. Subsequently we found a beach in Suffolk County (Cedar Beach County Park, Southold, Peconic Bay) where we can find large numbers consistently every time we visited in the fall (during scallop season). Of the hundreds I got, the largest was 11.9mm. they were almost always restricted to an upper driftline where they tended to wind up under rocks and gravel.... I have Suffolk County shells from nearby Greenport, and North Haven; and one very lucky find of a pair and single valve from Nassau County (bayside of Jones Beach State Park) from 2001, after rough weather."